How many times have we found ourselves in the same predicament, believing that the next promotion, raise, job, house, car, or life partner will bring the happiness and fulfillment we’ve always sought? It’s a familiar, rational thought. But what happens when we reach that milestone? The happiness we anticipated dissipates as quickly as the bubbles on promotion day.
This psychological trap has a name: the arrival fallacy.
Where the Idea Comes From
Harvard lecturer Tal Ben-Shahar, who popularized Positive Psychology, coined the term after noticing how we constantly looked to the next milestone for happiness. This observation, which is backed by behavioral science, is that when we finally “arrive,” we quickly adapt and then just reset our expectations, creating a cycle of chasing instead of savoring.
Many senior leaders today describe this same frustration: they hit their goals, only to feel strangely unfulfilled. Yale’s Laurie Santos, who teaches “The Science of Well-Being,” explains that our brains adapt rapidly to new circumstances, so the satisfaction of achievement vanishes sooner than expected.
Researcher and one of my favorite authors, Shawn Achor, flips the script entirely. Achor says that happiness isn’t the outcome of success; it’s the starting point. Another excellent speaker and author on the topic, Arthur Brooks, calls it the “striver’s curse”, which is defined as the paradox where relentless achievers feel emptiest because fulfillment always seems just out of reach.
Each expert underscores a truth that leaders rarely voice: milestones are mile markers, they are not destinations.
Why Leaders Are Especially Vulnerable
Leadership truly magnifies this arrival fallacy. Metrics, revenue targets, promotions, bonuses, and raises dominate the scoreboard. Every number promises validation; every win is meant to deliver lasting worth.
In today’s workplace, rushing from one project to the next, the space between milestones often feels like a holding pattern, not real progress. The problem is that this whole wait-for-the-next-win culture doesn’t really motivate, but rather it burns people out.
Suppose you are defining and emphasizing to your team that success only comes through such external results. In that case, you may be teaching your teams that their meaning as an employee is not in the present, but rather always down the road for the taking if only they do just one more thing. Eventually, morale will collapse between the victories, and organizational resilience will erode with it.
The Surprising Alternative
So if what all the researchers are saying is true, then what actually builds real fulfillment? The researchers who’ve studied this don’t say “achieve more.” There’s a unifying thread in each of the frameworks, and that is that the focus should be on the journey and not the outcome. For instance:
Tal Ben-Shahar’s SPIRE Model: Spiritual, Physical, Intellectual, Relational, and Emotional well-being is all about pursuing balance, not just finish lines. In other words, it is about savoring the moment.
Shawn Achor: Small habits like gratitude, journaling, and genuine connection cultivate happiness now. Achor reframes success as an outcome of happiness, not the other way around.
Arthur Brooks: Align goals with the daily practices of love and service instead of pure achievement.
Laurie Santos: She talks about how happiness is built in the doing, not in the arriving. This is the core idea behind the journey mindset.
None of them says “wait for happiness to arrive.” They all say, “build it through daily practice.”
A Personal Note: Running Without the Finish Line
I’ve learned this lesson of appreciating living in the moment as opposed to striving for continuous, never-ending finish lines through my marathon training. It’s easy to slip into the arrival fallacy thinking: “If I can just cross that one finish line, then I’ll be proud of myself.” But the real joy is in the training: the early mornings, the discipline, the quiet progress no one sees. The pleasure is in the running of the race itself and not the actual finish line. If I am only waiting for race day to feel fulfilled, I miss the gift of every run and every mile. This has translated and bled into my work life, into how I am a husband, and how I parent.
Leadership is literally no different. If celebration only happens at the finish, we rob ourselves and our teams of satisfaction in the journey.
What Leaders Can Do This Week
Here are four actionable ways to fight the arrival fallacy starting now:
At your next team meeting, make a point to celebrate not just the outcomes, but also the effort, learning, and improvement that went into achieving those results. This practice will inspire and motivate your team to focus on the journey, not just the destination. Model integrated well-being. Share how you’re caring for yourself physically, relationally, and emotionally—not just professionally.
Build meaning-making rituals. Begin meetings with reflections on progress or learning—close projects by discussing growth, not just results.
Ask present-focused questions. Swap “When will we finish?” for “What are we discovering right now?” or “How is this work changing us?”
The Leadership Reality Check
Some goals require delayed gratification (quarterly results matter; promotions create real impact). But sustainable fulfillment comes from daily practice, not deferred destiny. Great leaders help their teams hold both truths: achievements matter, but happiness isn’t waiting at a finish line.
Here’s the challenge:
If your team knew they’d stay in their current roles for the next three years, would they still find meaning and satisfaction in their daily work?
If the answer is no, you’ve built a culture trapped by the arrival fallacy. If it’s yes, you’ve created something rare, an organization that thrives now and in the future.
The arrival fallacy promises happiness just around the corner. Great leaders know better: fulfillment is built mile by mile, conversation by conversation, habit by habit.
True leadership is finding joy in the journey and helping others do the same.
Related Posts:
Download my Golden Leadership Cycle 90-day journal, which is a no-cost download to help you reflect deeply, lead intentionally, and grow with clarity, using prompts to journal on reinvention, resilience, and empowerment.
